Starts Monday 23 November

Black Friday: 50% off soon

First year half price on annual plans, or first 3 months on monthly.

See sale prices

Wealth and portfolio

How an Option Gain in One IRA Can Affect a Roth Conversion From Another

A fictional call gain in one traditional IRA changes the taxable share of a Roth conversion from another. See how Form 8606 uses year-end balances.

By Options Matrix Pro Editorial TeamPublished 6 min read
Share

In November 2026, a US investor completes a direct trustee-to-trustee conversion of $2,000 in cash from one traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. The example assumes zero withholding. In December, she closes a call for a $2,000 gain in a second traditional IRA and leaves the proceeds there. In this fictional example, the option gain raises the taxable portion of the November conversion from $1,500 to $1,600.

The conversion amount stays at $2,000. Its taxable portion goes on her 2026 federal return. A direct trustee-to-trustee conversion for 2026 must be completed by 31 December 2026. The December gain can change her estimate after the November conversion is final, and she cannot recharacterise the completed conversion back to a traditional IRA. IRS Form 8606 for 2026, IRS Publication 590-A and IRS IRA FAQs.

Add up the traditional IRAs at year-end

The investor starts with $2,000 of unused IRA basis from a prior nondeductible contribution. She converts all the cash in the IRA where she made that contribution. Her other traditional IRA was funded with pre-tax money, and it still holds assets on 31 December.

Form 8606 uses year-end values from all of her traditional IRAs. It also adds the amount she converted and any other distributions the form calls for. In this example, with a single conversion and no other distributions, rollovers or adjustments, the formula divides her $2,000 of unused basis by her combined 31 December traditional IRA balance plus the $2,000 conversion. Applying that pro-rata share to the $2,000 conversion gives the nontaxable amount. Traditional SEP and SIMPLE IRAs generally count in the calculation as well. IRS Form 8606 for 2026 and IRS Form 8606 instructions.

That calculation concerns money moved from an existing traditional IRA. An earlier example covers how an option gain in a taxable account can affect a direct Roth IRA contribution.

A December call sale changes the fraction

In both versions of the example, the second IRA buys one standard equity call for $2 per share, or $200 for the 100-share contract. The investor sells it to close in December before expiry. At an assumed $2 sale price, the trade breaks even before costs. At $22, it brings in $2,200, for a $2,000 gain after subtracting the original premium. The proceeds stay in the traditional IRA. All amounts are fictional US dollars. The model excludes fees and holds other account values fixed. Options Industry Council long-call guide.

2026 calculationCall sold for $2Call sold for $22
Combined 31 December traditional IRA balance$6,000$8,000
Balance plus the $2,000 already converted$8,000$10,000
Pro-rata nontaxable share ($2,000 basis divided by the row above)25%20%
Nontaxable portion of the $2,000 conversion$500$400
Taxable portion of the conversion$1,500$1,600
Unused basis carried forward$1,500$1,600

US federal income tax on traditional IRA gains is generally deferred until distribution. Here the retained call gain increases the year-end balance in the denominator and reduces the nontaxable pro-rata share from 25% to 20%. The resulting $100 increase in taxable conversion income adds to her ordinary income for 2026. IRS Publication 590-B and IRS Form 8606 for 2026.

In a taxable account, a net short-term capital gain from selling a comparable equity call generally enters taxable income for the year of the sale at ordinary rates. If additional income from a gain or conversion takes taxable income into a higher bracket, only the dollars in that higher bracket face its rate. IRS Schedule D instructions, IRS capital gains guidance and IRS federal income tax brackets.

What the option adds to the retirement plan

Option liquidity affects whether the account can realise the modelled gain. The $22 is an assumed execution price. A wide bid–ask spread or a lack of buyers can reduce the proceeds, and fees can trim them further.

Concentration matters even with a small premium. If the IRA already holds the underlying shares or a fund with a large holding in the same business, the call adds exposure to that business.

The option and the retirement account have different time horizons. A call held through expiry can lose the whole $200 premium if the stock finishes below the strike. A retirement plan can span decades. The option has a fixed strike and expiry. Options Industry Council long-call guide.

Funding depends on how the position ends. This investor sells to close, so she has no shares to buy. Exercising a call with a $45 strike would require funding a $4,500 stock purchase in the account that holds the call. The broker's expiry procedures and the IRA's available cash matter if the option is still open near its deadline. See what can happen when an expiring call lacks exercise funding. Options Industry Council long-call guide.

Later Roth withdrawals have two separate timing tests. A qualified distribution requires five tax years from the first tax year for which the investor made a Roth IRA contribution and a qualifying event, such as reaching age 59½. Each conversion has its own five-tax-year period starting with the conversion year. Before that period ends, a nonqualified withdrawal that the Roth ordering rules attribute to the taxable part of that conversion can trigger a 10% additional tax unless an exception applies. IRS Publication 590-B.

Check withholding and prior payments to see whether a federal estimated payment is due before filing. If a fourth-period instalment is owed for 2026, the general due date is 15 January 2027. A late-year change may affect that instalment, while any earlier-period shortfalls can still carry an underpayment penalty. IRS Publication 590-A and IRS Publication 505 for 2026.

At year-end, match the conversion on Form 1099-R with the conversion confirmation, pull the 31 December values from every relevant custodian, and retrieve the prior Form 8606 that supports the unused basis. Those records let a tax preparer reconcile the taxable amount after the final balances are known. IRS Form 8606 instructions.

Disclosure: Options Matrix Pro makes options-analysis software. General education, not financial advice. See our disclaimer.

Sources

Verified 21 Nov 2026

  1. 1IRS Form 8606 for 2026
  2. 2IRS Publication 590-A
  3. 3IRS IRA FAQs
  4. 4IRS Form 8606 instructions
  5. 5Options Industry Council long-call guide
  6. 6IRS Publication 590-B
  7. 7IRS Schedule D instructions
  8. 8IRS capital gains guidance
  9. 9IRS federal income tax brackets
  10. 10IRS Publication 505 for 2026

Test the framework against real options setups

Use the OMP Matrix, scanners and visualizer to compare yield, risk, liquidity and capital before making your own decision.